The protection of mako sharks under the EPBC act as of 29th January 2010
Is it Justified in Australian waters or an over reaction due to poor policy definition within our EPBC act
Firstly what is the EPBC act (the Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999)
The governmental description is as follows
The Environment Protection and
Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (the EPBC Act) is the Australian Government’s central piece of environmental legislation. The EPBC Act provides a legal framework to protect and manage nationally and internationally important flora, fauna, ecological communities and heritage places — defined in the Act as matters of national environmental significance. Listed migratory species are one of the matters of national environmental significance.
On the 5th of December 2008, 4 species of shark were added to the Conservation of migratory species act (CMS) act which is an international treaty act of which
The sharks were the porebeagle the long finned mako the short finned mako and the spiney dogfish
The spiney dogfish application was only for northern hemisphere
All sharks were added to Appendix11 of the treaty
Appendix I of the Convention lists migratory species in danger of extinction, while Appendix II lists species suffering from unfavorable conservation status and would benefit from international cooperation.
In Victorian game fishing circles there are realistically the following species to target
Southern bluefin tuna and albacore (normally only caught from Warrnambool to the west and long range offshore) kingfish and the following sharks Common thresher, Bronze whaler, and Short finned mako with the Mako shark being the most common game fish encountered in the state and the only one realistically within reach of most metropolitan anglers
It is also in my opinion the best eating of the above species
So now some facts about mako sharks in Australian waters
It is proven using both historical tagging data and pop up satellite data the Mako sharks in and around Australian waters do not migrate to the northern hemisphere and do not migrate east west inter ocean
Whilst makos tagged in
The CMS description is as follows
Species included in this analysis appear, on the basis of current information, to fall under the definition given in Article I of CMS i.e. “the entire population or any geographically separate part of the population of any species or lower tax on of wild animals, a significant proportion of whose members cyclically and predictably cross one or more national jurisdictional boundaries”.
For the purposes of migratory marine species, national jurisdictional boundaries are taken to include not just national boundaries between States, but also the boundaries between the high seas (those that do not fall under the jurisdiction of any State) and States’ Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) or territorial waters (where no EEZ as been declared).
Under this definition:
i) The word “cyclically” in the phrase “cyclically and predictably” relates to a cycle of any nature, such as astronomical (circadian, annual etc.), life or climatic, and of any frequency.
ii) The word “predictably” in the phrase “cyclically and predictably” implies that a phenomenon can be anticipated to recur in a given set of circumstances, though not necessarily regularly in time.
iii) National jurisdictional boundaries include national land and territorial sea borders, and the outer 200mile EEZ boundary of each nation where this has been declared.
In excess of 11500 mako sharks have been tagged in Australian waters and currently it is only a rarity that these sharks have ever been recaptured outside Australian waters
The South Australian Research and Development institute have been undertaking a pop up satellite tagging program of mako sharks for just over 2 years now and it clearly shows there is NO set pattern as per the description if migratory listed above (predictable patterns)
Some of these sharks have been transmitting for in excess of 600 days
Economically figures just released by VR fish show Victorians spend 2.7 billion dollars annually on recreational fishing and a large proportion of this is on Game fishing. This will put a huge dent into the retail tackle trade and charter boat trade in Victoria South Australia Tasmania and
4 major sanctioned game fishing tournaments in
In
Danny Standing from the Bass Strait Game Fishing Club last year won the prestigious “MOST TAGGED SHARKS AUSTRALIA” trophy with all of his tagged fish coming from Victorian waters
Well Known marine Biologist DR Julian Pepperell was quoted in the Daily Telegraph saying
"There is a fishing competition in
So the questions Remain
Because the Australian EPBC act does not differentiate between appendix1 and appendix11 on the CMS list we as a nation are forced to list the species as fully protected in Commonwealth waters.
Is this just and “in
Are mako sharks in Australian Waters Migratory or do they swim randomly following a food source
The Government release says they can still be taken professionally on long lines if they are dead when bought to the boat and fall under section 13 of the act allowing up to 20 per trip as a “BYCATCH” but is a recreational angler accidentally hooks one and it dies or is injured during the fight it must be cut off and allowed to sink
A Recreational angle cannot target them outside 3 NM from the state coastline but inside that area it is still legal
Therefore anglers can start a burley trail inside this 3 NM limit and fish for them???? That might make swimming in ocean beaches interesting
The Biggest question is “Are mako sharks in Australian waters under as bigger threat as they are internationally and will blanket protecting them from Recreational fishing in Australian waters assist in the re stocking of them in the Mediterranean sea and other parts of the Northern Hemisphere
Another feature to be aware of is there are only a select few countries bound by this treaty and it should be noted that the U.S.A. Japan China Indonesia,
In My opinion we should be pressing world wide for a total ban on the practice of finning sharks at sea and in fact this barbaric practice is only banned by 19 countries world wide but recreational fishing for makos will be banned by 96 Only 96 of the world 195 countries are party to the Bonn convention
In My opinion We should have a provision in our EPBC act to allow for appendix 11 listed species
In my opinion short finned mako sharks (the most prolific of the 3 species listed) should be made exempt in Commonwealth waters under Section a303 of the act
The other 2 species are not a common target species for Recreational or Professional fishermen in Australian waters and it would not be detrimental to have those 2 species listed
Has the Hon MR Peter Garret and the Department of Environment Water and The Arts over reacted to be seen as Green internationally
GETTING YOUR KIDS INTO FISHING
Surprising as it may seem, we (blokes) are not the only ones who seek peace and solitude on the week end. We may find our peace and solitude in the maddening crowds at the ramps and roads and on our waterways, whilst our other halves (or so I am told) crave 5 minutes peace and quiet to themselves.
Imagine sitting down on the couch on a spring or summers morning channel surfing in the peace and quiet or fishing for those adrenalin pumping snapper or the wily whiting or sitting on a riverbank chasing bream
A few years back I was packing the boat on a Friday night getting it ready for an early start on Port Phillip Bay chasing the November snapper run. The wife pops out with a coffee and says “hey I wouldn’t mind going shopping tomorrow why don’t you take the kids and I will meet you ant Frankston pier for lunch”
Hang on a minute how the bloody hell am I going to get the kids up at 3 in the morning and bundled into the car, then out of the car and into the boat, ??????
Then again I started fishing at 5 years of age and my girls had fished in rivers and dams and had been in the boat, how hard can it be
So I asked the girls hey wanna come fishin with dear old dad in the morning, you can sleep on the couch tonight and I will get you up bright and early
So My kids packed food and drink for themselves and for me (no fruit at all in case it’s a distant relative of a banana) into the boat and at 3am I got them up and off we went
The look on my daughters face when she caught her first snapper was priceless to say the least and even my youngest had a blast getting amongst them too but to me the most rewarding thing was their enthusiasm and the smiles on their faces
Granted it was a perfect day on PPB but many days haven’t been and they still enjoy it
Whether its catching whiting or gummies or sitting on the banks of a high country trout stream they like their fishing
Now they are a bit older maybe they don’t come out as much as they used to or I meet them at lunchtime for a ski or a wakeboard (after I have fished first light with the wife)
Now getting your kids involved at first means keeping it simple and fish like pinkies and flatties are a good place to start. Even large snapper are reasonably good to get kids hooked on but remember to keep it interesting
Be prepared for a bit of line twist from reels wound whilst line is peeling and be prepared for tangles etc but most of this goes away after 2 or 3 trips
Most of all let them enjoy it and encourage them constantly
Simple rods and reels (even ones Santa can bring) their own life jackets (a must) and a good healthy lesson on taking only what you need and releasing undersize fish will stand them in good stead and you can bet their children, and their children’s children, will thank you.
And I bet the wife will too


THE HOME OF VICTORIAN SALTWATER FISHING 


